Buying a Pre-Owned Luxury Watch: What to Check and Online Red Flags

Before you buy a pre-owned luxury watch, confirm the reference and serial, inspect the case, dial and bracelet, check that it keeps time and works properly, and review the paperwork. Online, walk away from prices far below market, sellers who won't show the watch on video, and pressure to pay fast by untraceable methods.

The checklist

Check What to look for
Reference and serial Match the model, dial and paperwork
Dial and hands Crisp printing, even lume, no moisture or spots
Case and bezel Sharp lines, no heavy over-polishing, bezel turns correctly
Bracelet Stretch, clasp security, all links included
Movement Keeps time; winding, date and chronograph work
Paperwork Card, box, service records. See Box and Papers
Modifications Aftermarket diamonds, dials or bezels. See Aftermarket vs Factory

Online red flags

  • A price far below every comparable listing
  • Stock photos only, or refusal to send a live video
  • No physical address or phone number
  • Pressure to pay quickly with gift cards, crypto or wire only
  • Vague answers about condition, papers or service history

Buying from us

Every watch we list shows what we know about its condition and papers, and if we don't know something we say so. Ask for more photos or a video anytime. Browse watches or call or text (973) 673-3800.

Golden Palace Jewelry is an independent dealer and is not affiliated with or authorized by Rolex or any watch brand mentioned.

Back to The Journal

More in Buying Guides

Keep reading

View all

Questions? Ask the family behind the counter.

30 years at 260 Main St, Orange, NJ. Open 7 days. Call or text (973) 673-3800.

Design Your NameplateShop Gold ChainsCall or Text